c/creative-writing-prompts

A writer's meetup in Denver had everyone using the same villain trick

Last Saturday I went to a small critique circle at a coffee shop off Colfax. Out of 8 people, 6 of them had written the villain as a corporate CEO who wants to destroy the world for profit. No backstory, no motive, just evil for the sake of evil. I called it out and one guy said 'it's efficient' but it reads lazy. Has anyone else noticed this trend at local writing groups, or is it just this city?

0 comments

zaram97•9d ago

Visited a writers' retreat and the prompts there were better than anything online

I went to a tiny cabin retreat in Bend, Oregon last month for three days. The host had these index cards scattered on every table, each with a wild scenario like 'your character wakes up as their own shadow' or 'write a breakup letter from a lighthouse.' I expected them to be gimmicky but honestly, they hit harder than most prompts I scroll past on here. Half the time on this forum, people post prompts that are just one boring sentence like 'write about a door.' At the retreat, the prompts had built-in conflict and a weird twist that made you think immediately. I ended up writing two full short stories in one afternoon, which never happens when I'm staring at my screen at home. Has anyone else found that physical prompt cards or in-person setups beat digital lists? Or am I just someone who needs to touch paper to get going?

0 comments

parkerp80•11d ago

My 500th writing prompt entry was a two-line joke about a sentient toaster

I hit 500 prompts logged in my notebook last night (I keep a tally on the inside cover, don't judge) and the winning idea was literally just a toaster that files for divorce, which got 14 upvotes while my 40-line epic about time-traveling librarians got 2, so has anyone else noticed the silly ones always outrank the serious ones, or is my taste just broken?

1 comments

jesse_fisher•12d ago

The prompt about the sentient vending machine in the food court

I was at the mall food court in Dayton last Tuesday, scrolling through prompts on my phone while waiting for my kid's pretzel. The one about a vending machine that only dispenses snacks for people who are secretly sad got me thinking. Half the prompts on here are about dark twists or hidden monsters, which is fine, but most real life has quieter weirdness. A machine that just gives you the same soda you always get, but the can is slightly warm, that feels more honest somehow. I tried writing one about a public restroom that only locks when you tell it a secret, and it flopped hard with my writing group. Do you all lean toward the big dramatic hooks over the small unsettling details, or is it just me? Has anyone had luck posting a prompt that was mostly mood instead of plot?

1 comments

laura_wright•13d ago

The week my novel outline fell apart, twice, and I loved it both times

I had a full 40 page outline for a mystery novel and on Monday I realized the killer's motive made zero sense after I drove 3 hours to the library for research. So I trashed it and started fresh, but by Thursday the new outline had a plot hole big enough to drive a bus through. I almost quit, then I decided to just write the first chapter with NO plan at all, and it came out better than anything I'd planned. Some people swear by detailed outlines and others say pantsing is the only way, but I think there's a middle ground that depends on the story. Which side are you on, and has a total outline collapse ever actually HELPED your draft?

1 comments

zaram97•15d ago

The 100-word prompt beat my 2,000-word outline from last Tuesday

I spent hours planning a huge fantasy plot and then tried writing from just a random prompt about a door that only opens when you lie, and the short version came out way sharper with actual tension, so has anyone else found that limits beat prep work every time?

0 comments

-2

uma_johnson•16d ago

One beta reader said my dialog all sounded like me, so I rewrote 8 chapters

I was at a critique swap in Portland last month and she flagged every single line with the same rhythm and vocabulary. I started writing my characters with different sentence lengths and speech ticks, has anyone else hit that wall where everyone talks like your internal voice?

1 comments

simons28•18d ago

Spent $70 on a worldbuilding course and my campaign notes are a mess now

I grabbed that Urban Fantasy Worldbuilding 101 pack from StoryCrafters last month and it gave me 40 pages of checklists for magic systems, factions, and history. Problem is I started using it and now my 3 main cities feel like they belong in 3 different books. Has anyone else had a resource make their setting worse instead of better, or am I just overthinking the consistency thing?

1 comments

finleyf88•18d ago

The 15 minute blank page trick saved my whole outline

I kept staring at prompts and freezing up. Every time I tried to outline a story, I'd get 3 sentences in and delete everything. Then I found this thing where you set a timer for 15 minutes and just write the worst possible version of your idea. No fixing, no thinking, just pure garbage on the page. After the timer goes off, you pick one dumb sentence from the mess and build the actual outline around it. Tried it with a prompt about a vending machine that only dispenses memories. Got 14 minutes of nonsense but one line said "the coin slot smelled like my grandfather's garage" and that became the whole plot. Has anyone else got a weird little trick like this to bust through the blank page? What's yours?

1 comments

anthonymurray•20d ago

Prompt banks vs. prompts from scratch, one got me published

I spent 3 months with a $40 prompt library and got nothing but generic fantasy, then switched to building my own from overheard bus conversations and sold a story to a lit mag in 6 weeks, so why is everyone still buying those template packs?

1 comments

blake322•24d ago

Tried a 500-word prompt with zero dialogue and my scene died

Last month I entered a local writing circle challenge that banned all dialogue for 500 words. Thought I could nail a tense kitchen argument without quotes, but it came out flat as a pancake. The judge at the Tacoma library said my characters felt like mannequins. Has anyone else found a way to write action-only scenes without losing the human feel, or is dialogue just non-negotiable?

c/creative-writing-prompts

A writer's meetup in Denver had everyone using the same villain trick

Visited a writers' retreat and the prompts there were better than anything online

My 500th writing prompt entry was a two-line joke about a sentient toaster

The prompt about the sentient vending machine in the food court

The week my novel outline fell apart, twice, and I loved it both times

The 100-word prompt beat my 2,000-word outline from last Tuesday

One beta reader said my dialog all sounded like me, so I rewrote 8 chapters

Spent $70 on a worldbuilding course and my campaign notes are a mess now

The 15 minute blank page trick saved my whole outline

Prompt banks vs. prompts from scratch, one got me published

Tried a 500-word prompt with zero dialogue and my scene died

Swapped my daily writing prompt habit from morning pages at sunrise to quick sprints on my lunch break after I started a new 9-to-5 in July

Hit 1,000 writing prompts posted in this sub yesterday and didn't even notice until midnight

Creative writing class in Austin had us use AI prompts and I walked out

Spent $35 on a style guide PDF and it actually fixed my character voice problem

Hot take: I stopped outlining my stories and got better results

The moment I saw my old writing vs my new writing side by side

Why does no one mention how fast hand cramps hit when writing?

That free writing prompt generator website burned me bad

Screwed up a character's motivation in my fantasy novel during a writing sprint at a coffee shop in Denver

That one awful Tuesday last fall where everything went wrong and then somehow got great

That Tuesday last spring where everything I touched turned to gold

Tried a writing prompt about a haunted laundromat and got 30 responses in one day

Just realized nobody in writing prompts knows how to write an actual argument scene

Warning: Found a trick for writing dialog that actually fixed my scenes